I like the first cockerel better. He has better coloring. The second one has a better top line, but the blonde feathers to me, are a fault. He either has silver or red leakage. I culled four lavender cockerels with leakage about a month ago.
You should probably be able to produce a better cockerel this year with your crosses that posess better size, type and color.
Have you weighed them? I have a couple split cockerels running around right now. I am going to weigh them all before I make a final decision on which one to use.
Good luck, I think we are all in the same boat as far as what to keep. Just be very picky.